You get a tax position settled once and then defended wherever it is questioned. Audits, investigations and show cause notices are answered at the stage when the record is still being made, because the reply to the first notice is the document every later forum is confined to. We appear before the adjudicating authorities, the Commissioner (Appeals), the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal, the Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal and the High Courts, and take a point higher where it will not be settled below. Customs and foreign trade work sits on the same file as indirect tax, so a valuation dispute, an exemption condition and an export obligation are held by one team rather than three advisers. Where the answer lies with a government instead of a tribunal, the case is made there. Filings and appearances in States where we do not sit go through associate counsel the firm instructs and pays.
A manufacturing group
The group carried ₹1,400 crore of legacy Central Sales Tax under the erstwhile Punjab value added tax regime, and the State settlement scheme was capped far below that figure, which left the liability unresolved and the State unpaid. An appeal would have decided nothing. We represented the group before the Government of Punjab for removal of the cap. An expanded scheme was approved by the Cabinet and promulgated.



